Tyler triggering his werewolf curse again by killing Liv felt like a step backward for his character, making his storyline seem repetitive.

Kai Parker solidified his spot as one of the best villains in the show's history. His cruelty at the wedding and his sadistic linking of Bonnie and Elena's lives kept the episode pulse-pounding and dark. 📉 Low Points

The Vampire Diaries season 6 episode 22 review - Den of Geek

The episode's true core rests on Damon’s shoulders. The "old" Damon would have let Bonnie die to keep Elena awake. Choosing to save Bonnie and wait 60+ years for Elena proved his ultimate redemption and cemented his character development.

The Gemini Coven was eliminated quickly due to Kai's temporary death to prepare for the next season's villains (The Heretics). Many felt this cut off a rich storyline prematurely.

Critics and fans largely agree that episode 6x22 is a masterclass in handling a major cast departure. Instead of abruptly killing off Elena, the writers crafted a clever magical loophole that respected her character's journey while leaving the door cracked open for her eventual return. 📈 High Points