The Maurice Lenell Cooky Company has a long, complicated history that led to its current status:
: The best place to find vintage collectible Maurice Lenell tins for your collection. Why Are They So Hard to Find?
: A seasonal pop-up in Norridge, IL, that offers a 9-cookie assortment similar to the old holiday tins. buy maurice lenell cookies
While the original factory is closed, these sources offer the closest match to the classic Chicago taste:
If you can't find a store that ships to you, many fans have turned to home baking. Several blogs provide recipes to mimic that specific "stiff, rich, slightly salty" profile: The Maurice Lenell Cooky Company has a long,
: Filed for bankruptcy and was bought by Consolidated Biscuit Co..
: Sells a highly-rated "recreation" of the famous Pinwheel cookie based on original memory and testing. While the original factory is closed, these sources
: They explicitly state they do not have Pinwheels or Jelly Stars, but offer alternatives like Butterscotch and English Toffee.