Reviews of the track were generally positive, though some critics found certain elements "pedestrian" compared to the band's historic hits.
: Critics highlight the second verse as particularly poignant for its simple yet heavy emotional weight: "If you wanted out / Didn't I let you go / If you wanted in / Didn't I make it so" . Musical Composition & Style a_ha_under_the_makeup_lyric
: Some critics felt the chorus lacked the strong melodic hooks of typical radio-friendly singles, and some perceived it as a "rip-off" or "sister song" to their 1988 hit "Stay On These Roads" . Reviews of the track were generally positive, though
: Produced by Paul Waaktaar-Savoy and Erik Ljunggren , the track starts with a sparse piano accompaniment before building into a "boombastic" orchestral finish. Critical Reception : Produced by Paul Waaktaar-Savoy and Erik Ljunggren
: On community sites like Rate Your Music , the single holds a moderate rating of approximately 3.24/5 . 'Under The Makeup' (Official Music Video)
: The "makeup" serves as a metaphor for the masks people wear in relationships. The narrator expresses a longing to see their partner without these layers—"I want to see you under the makeup"—to rediscover the original connection they once shared.
The song's lyrics, written by guitarist , explore the universal theme of the loss of love and the desire for genuine vulnerability.