: Often cited as the most polarizing hero, Buffy’s younger sister is frequently criticized for her "whiny" teenager persona. Despite her supernatural origin as "The Key," many fans struggled with her high-pitched outbursts and frequent kidnappings that sidelined Buffy's own development.
: Unlike many brooding demons, The Mayor was a cheerful, germaphobic, and fatherly figure—who also happened to be an immortal warlock. His genuine, wholesome love for Faith provided a fascinating contrast to his plans for world domination. : Often cited as the most polarizing hero,
: As a literal god from a hell dimension, Glory was a breath of fresh air in Season 5. Fans adored her high-fashion vanity, her witty dialogue, and the sheer power she possessed, making her one of the most entertaining and formidable threats the Slayer ever faced. His genuine, wholesome love for Faith provided a
: Introduced in the final season, Kennedy faced an uphill battle as Willow’s first major love interest after the tragic death of Tara. Fans often viewed her as pushy, arrogant, and an inadequate replacement for the beloved Tara Maclay. : Introduced in the final season, Kennedy faced
: While a core member of the Scoobies, Xander has faced modern scrutiny for what many describe as toxic behavior . His tendency to "shame" Buffy for her sexual choices and his often entitled attitude toward the women in the group have made him a lightning rod for debate.
: The "dark reflection" of Buffy, Faith’s rebellious energy and tragic backstory made her deeply sympathetic. Fans loved her leather-clad aesthetic and her journey toward redemption, viewing her more as a misunderstood victim of circumstance than a pure villain.
: Though primarily an Angel character, Connor’s cross-over legacy is one of near-universal fan frustration. As the surly, easily manipulated teenage son of Angel and Darla, his actions—including trapping his father in a crate at the bottom of the ocean—made him a difficult hero to root for. 5 Villains Fans Can’t Help But Love